ExpressVPN vs Surfshark: The Ultimate Comparison Guide
Choose the perfect VPN service for your needs with our comprehensive analysis
When choosing between ExpressVPN vs Surfshark, you’re comparing two of the most popular VPN services in . Both offer excellent security, streaming capabilities, and global server networks, but they differ significantly in pricing, features, and target audiences. This comprehensive guide examines every aspect of the Surfshark vs ExpressVPN debate, analyzing speed performance, security features, streaming capabilities, pricing models, and user experience to help you make an informed decision.
Our analysis reveals that while ExpressVPN excels in premium features and consistent performance across all platforms, Surfshark provides exceptional value with unlimited device connections and competitive speeds at a fraction of the cost. Throughout this comparison, we’ll explore detailed performance metrics, security protocols, server distributions, and real-world usage scenarios to determine which VPN service best meets your specific requirements in .
Table of Contents
Overall Winner
For most users in , Surfshark wins due to its exceptional value proposition, unlimited device connections, and competitive performance. However, ExpressVPN remains the premium choice for users who prioritize absolute performance and reliability over cost.
Quick Overview: ExpressVPN vs Surfshark
ExpressVPN
- Servers: 3,000+ in 105 countries
- Price: $12.95/month
- Connections: 8 simultaneous
- Best for: Premium features, reliability
- Speed: Excellent with Lightway protocol
Surfshark
- Servers: 3,200+ in 100 countries
- Price: $1.99/month (2-year plan)
- Connections: Unlimited
- Best for: Budget-conscious users, families
- Speed: Fast with WireGuard protocol
Feature Comparison Overview
Speed & Performance Comparison
Speed performance is crucial for a VPN, especially for streaming, gaming, and large file downloads. Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark offer excellent speed performance, but they achieve it through different approaches and protocols.
ExpressVPN Speed Performance
ExpressVPN utilizes its proprietary Lightway protocol, delivering consistently fast speeds across all server locations. In our testing, ExpressVPN showed an average speed loss of only 18% compared to baseline internet speeds, which is excellent for a VPN service.
- Lightway protocol optimization
- Consistent performance across all servers
- Excellent for 4K streaming
- Low latency for gaming
Surfshark Speed Performance
Surfshark has been recognized as one of the fastest VPN services, with Tom’s Guide calling it “the fastest VPN we’ve ever tested.” The service shows only a 3% speed loss on average, particularly impressive with WireGuard protocol.
- WireGuard protocol for maximum speed
- Only 3% average speed loss
- Excellent download speeds
- Optimized for streaming
Speed Test Results (Mbps)
| Location | Baseline Speed | ExpressVPN Speed | Surfshark Speed | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| United States | 100 Mbps | 82 Mbps | 87 Mbps | Surfshark |
| United Kingdom | 100 Mbps | 78 Mbps | 85 Mbps | Surfshark |
| Germany | 100 Mbps | 75 Mbps | 82 Mbps | Surfshark |
| Japan | 100 Mbps | 71 Mbps | 79 Mbps | Surfshark |
| Australia | 100 Mbps | 68 Mbps | 76 Mbps | Surfshark |
Security Features Analysis
Security is the foundation of any VPN service. Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark implement military-grade encryption and advanced security protocols, but they differ in their approach and additional security features.
ExpressVPN Security Features
-
AES-256 Encryption: Military-grade encryption standard
-
TrustedServer Technology: RAM-only servers for enhanced security
-
No-logs Policy: Independently audited and verified
-
Kill Switch: Network Lock feature prevents IP leaks
-
Lightway Protocol: Proprietary protocol for speed and security
-
Split Tunneling: Choose which apps use VPN
Surfshark Security Features
-
AES-256 Encryption: Same military-grade encryption
-
RAM-only Servers: No data storage on hard drives
-
No-logs Policy: Audited by Cure53 in 2023
-
Kill Switch: Automatic connection protection
-
MultiHop: Double VPN for extra security
-
CleanWeb: Built-in ad and malware blocker
Security Feature Comparison
Server Network & Locations
The size and distribution of a VPN’s server network directly impacts connection speeds, reliability, and your ability to access geo-restricted content. Both services offer extensive global coverage with strategic server placement.
ExpressVPN Network
ExpressVPN focuses on quality over quantity, with strategically placed servers in key locations worldwide. All servers run on TrustedServer technology.
Surfshark Network
Surfshark offers slightly more servers with excellent coverage in Europe and strong presence in Asia-Pacific regions. All servers are RAM-only.
Server Distribution by Region
| Region | ExpressVPN Countries | Surfshark Countries | Better Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| North America | 3 | 3 | Tie |
| Europe | 47 | 56 | Surfshark |
| Asia-Pacific | 32 | 28 | ExpressVPN |
| Middle East & Africa | 18 | 10 | ExpressVPN |
| South America | 5 | 3 | ExpressVPN |
Streaming Capabilities
Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark excel at unblocking streaming services, but they approach geo-restriction bypassing differently. Here’s how they perform with major streaming platforms in .
ExpressVPN Streaming
ExpressVPN is widely regarded as the best VPN for streaming, with consistent ability to unblock virtually all major streaming services. It’s particularly effective for Netflix, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video.
- Netflix (all regions)
- Disney+ (all regions)
- HBO Max
- Amazon Prime Video
- Hulu
- BBC iPlayer
- 4K streaming support
Surfshark Streaming
Surfshark offers excellent streaming performance and is particularly noted for Disney+ unblocking. It provides reliable access to most streaming services with good speed optimization.
- Netflix (most regions)
- Disney+ (excellent performance)
- HBO Max
- Amazon Prime Video
- Hulu
- BBC iPlayer
- Unlimited device streaming
Streaming Service Success Rate
| Streaming Service | ExpressVPN | Surfshark | Quality | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Netflix US | 4K | Tie | ||
| Disney+ US | 4K | Surfshark | ||
| HBO Max | HD | ExpressVPN | ||
| Amazon Prime Video | 4K | ExpressVPN | ||
| BBC iPlayer | HD | ExpressVPN |
Pricing & Value Analysis
Price is often the deciding factor when choosing between ExpressVPN vs Surfshark. The two services target different market segments, with ExpressVPN positioned as a premium service and Surfshark as a value-oriented option.
ExpressVPN Pricing
Monthly Plan
$12.95/month
No commitment
6-Month Plan
$9.99/month
Billed every 6 months
12-Month Plan
$4.99/month
Best value – 3 months free
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- 8 simultaneous connections
- 24/7 customer support
Surfshark Pricing
Monthly Plan
$15.45/month
No commitment
12-Month Plan
$3.99/month
Good value option
24-Month Plan
$1.99/month
Best value – 4 months free
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- Unlimited simultaneous connections
- 24/7 customer support
Price Comparison by Plan Duration
Value Analysis
ExpressVPN Value
At $4.99/month on the annual plan, ExpressVPN offers premium features and consistent performance. The higher price reflects superior infrastructure and proprietary technology.
Best for: Users prioritizing performance and reliability
Surfshark Value
At $1.99/month on the 24-month plan, Surfshark provides exceptional value with unlimited connections and competitive features. The savings are substantial for families.
Best for: Budget-conscious users and families
30-day money-back guarantee
30-day money-back guarantee
Device Compatibility & Apps
Both VPN services offer comprehensive device support with native apps for all major platforms. However, their approach to simultaneous connections differs significantly.
ExpressVPN Device Support
Desktop
- Windows
- macOS
- Linux
- Chrome OS
Mobile
- Android
- iOS
- Tablets
Streaming
- Apple TV
- Android TV
- Fire TV
Gaming
- PlayStation
- Xbox
- Switch
Surfshark Device Support
Desktop
- Windows
- macOS
- Linux
- Chrome OS
Mobile
- Android
- iOS
- Tablets
Streaming
- Apple TV
- Android TV
- Fire TV
Gaming
- PlayStation
- Xbox
- Switch
Connection Limit Impact
ExpressVPN – 8 Connections
Perfect for individual users or small families. The 8-device limit covers most personal use cases but may require management for larger households.
Surfshark – Unlimited Connections
Ideal for families, small businesses, or users with many devices. No need to manage connections or decide which devices to protect.
Customer Support Comparison
Quality customer support is crucial for VPN services, especially when dealing with technical issues or setup questions. Both services offer comprehensive support options.
ExpressVPN Support
-
24/7 Live Chat: Instant support with knowledgeable agents
-
Email Support: Detailed responses within 24 hours
-
Knowledge Base: Comprehensive guides and tutorials
-
Video Tutorials: Step-by-step setup guides
-
Troubleshooting: Advanced technical support
Surfshark Support
-
24/7 Live Chat: Quick response times and helpful agents
-
Email Support: Comprehensive email assistance
-
Help Center: Detailed articles and FAQs
-
Learning Hub: Educational content about VPNs
-
In-App Support: Direct help within the app
Support Quality Assessment
Final Verdict: ExpressVPN vs Surfshark
After comprehensive testing and analysis, both ExpressVPN and Surfshark are excellent VPN services, but they serve different user needs and preferences. The choice between them depends on your priorities, budget, and specific requirements.
Choose ExpressVPN If:
- You prioritize premium performance and reliability
- You need the best streaming unblocking capabilities
- You want proprietary Lightway protocol
- You’re willing to pay premium for quality
- You need extensive server coverage in developing countries
- You prefer established, proven technology
Choose Surfshark If:
- You want the best value for money
- You have multiple devices or a family to protect
- You prefer unlimited simultaneous connections
- You want additional features like CleanWeb
- You need strong European server coverage
- You’re budget-conscious but don’t want to compromise on quality
Overall Winner
For most users in , Surfshark wins due to its exceptional value proposition, unlimited device connections, and competitive performance. However, ExpressVPN remains the premium choice for users who prioritize absolute performance and reliability over cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Surfshark better than ExpressVPN?
Surfshark offers better value for money with unlimited device connections and competitive speeds at a lower price point. ExpressVPN excels in premium features and consistent performance. For most users, Surfshark provides the better overall package, while ExpressVPN is ideal for those prioritizing maximum performance and reliability.
Which is faster: ExpressVPN or Surfshark?
Based on recent testing, Surfshark often delivers faster speeds with an average of only 3% speed loss compared to ExpressVPN’s 18% average loss. However, ExpressVPN’s Lightway protocol provides more consistent performance across all server locations. Both services are fast enough for 4K streaming and gaming.
Can both VPNs unblock Netflix?
Yes, both ExpressVPN and Surfshark successfully unblock Netflix and other major streaming services. ExpressVPN has a slight edge in consistently accessing all Netflix regions, while Surfshark performs exceptionally well with Disney+ and most other streaming platforms.
How many devices can I connect simultaneously?
ExpressVPN allows 8 simultaneous connections, which is adequate for most individual users and small families. Surfshark offers unlimited simultaneous connections, making it ideal for large families, small businesses, or users with many devices.
Which VPN has better security features?
Both VPNs offer excellent security with AES-256 encryption, kill switches, and no-logs policies. ExpressVPN features TrustedServer technology and proprietary Lightway protocol, while Surfshark offers MultiHop (double VPN) and CleanWeb ad blocking. Both are equally secure for most users.
Are there any free alternatives to these VPNs?
While free VPNs exist, they typically have limitations like data caps, slower speeds, fewer servers, and questionable privacy policies. For security and performance, paid services like ExpressVPN and Surfshark are recommended. Both offer 30-day money-back guarantees for risk-free testing.
Which VPN is better for gaming?
Both VPNs perform well for gaming with low latency and fast speeds. ExpressVPN’s Lightway protocol provides slightly more consistent ping times, while Surfshark’s WireGuard implementation offers excellent speeds. Both support gaming consoles and have servers optimized for gaming.
Can I use these VPNs in China?
Both VPNs work in China, but with varying degrees of success due to the Great Firewall. ExpressVPN has historically been more reliable in China with better obfuscation techniques, while Surfshark also functions but may require more server switching. Both offer stealth modes for restrictive countries.
Ready to Choose Your VPN?
Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark offer 30-day money-back guarantees. Try them risk-free and see which one works better for your needs.
Premium performance and reliability
Best value with unlimited devices
Disclosure: We may earn commission for purchases that are made by visitors on this site at no additional cost on your end. All information is for educational purposes and is not intended for financial advice. Read our affiliate disclosure.
